Beijing Silk Market vs Shanghai AP Plaza: What Tourists Should Know
Two markets, two cities, one reputation. The Beijing Silk Market (Xiushui Street) and Shanghai’s AP Plaza are China’s two most famous tourist markets — the places where generations of travelers have haggled over designer-lookalike bags, silk scarves, watches, and sneakers. If your itinerary forces a choice, or you want to know what you’re walking into at either one, this is the comparison you need.
The headline verdict: AP Plaza wins on price and depth for knockoff fashion; the Silk Market wins on accessibility, silk goods, and sheer spectacle. But the details matter — prices, quality tiers, opening hours, and bargaining culture differ more than you’d expect. Here’s everything tourists should know, plus how to get the best of whichever one you visit.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Factor | Beijing Silk Market | Shanghai AP Plaza |
|---|---|---|
| Location | 8 Xiushui East Street, Chaoyang | Inside Science & Technology Museum Station, Pudong |
| Metro | Line 1, Yong’anli Station (Exit A1) | Line 2, Science & Technology Museum Station |
| Format | 7-story indoor mall | Underground stall bazaar |
| Size | ~1,700 stalls | ~400–600 stalls |
| Signature goods | Silk, clothing, bags, accessories | Bags, watches, sneakers, electronics |
| Tourist polish | High — English spoken, prices in USD/EUR | Medium — basic English, yuan pricing |
| Price level | Higher (pure tourist traffic) | Lower (mixed local/tourist traffic) |
| Bargaining intensity | Aggressive but polished | Aggressive and theatrical |
| Best time | Weekday mornings | Weekday afternoons |
| Hours | ~9:30 a.m. – 9 p.m. daily | ~10 a.m. – 8 p.m. daily |
Hours and tenant mix change — check recent reviews before visiting.
Beijing Silk Market: What You’re Walking Into
The Silk Market is a Beijing institution. The original outdoor alley market on Xiushui Street was legendary in the 1990s — a chaotic lane of counterfeit everything that diplomats’ spouses and backpackers raided in equal measure. In 2005 it moved into a modern seven-story building, and while the chaos was tamed, the DNA survived.
Floor by floor (roughly):
- Floors 1–3: Bags, wallets, watches, sneakers, and clothing — the counterfeit core, with quality tiers from obvious fakes to back-room “AAA grade”
- Floors 4–5: Silk garments, bedding, scarves, and tailoring — the market’s legitimate heritage
- Upper floors: Jewelry, electronics accessories, souvenirs, and tea
What makes it distinctive:
- Vendors routinely speak functional English (some Russian and French too) and quote in your home currency
- The silk sections are genuinely good — silk shirts, dresses, and duvet covers at prices well below Western retail
- It’s walkable from the CBD and one stop from Jianguomen — easy to combine with the Forbidden City day
The catch: Its fame is its weakness. The crowd is almost entirely foreign tourists, and prices reflect it — opening quotes here run higher than anywhere else in China, and even after bargaining you’ll often pay 20–30% more than at AP Plaza for identical goods.
Stay nearby: Hotels around Guomao and Jianguomen put you one stop away — compare Beijing hotels on Trip.com.
Shanghai AP Plaza: What You’re Walking Into
AP Plaza hides in plain sight: the entire market is underground, inside the Science & Technology Museum metro station (Line 2) in Pudong, beneath a legitimate shopping mall. First-timers walk past the mall entrances and wonder if the market still exists — it does, down the escalators, a sprawling maze of narrow alleys packed with small stalls.
What makes it distinctive:
- The setting — a genuine bazaar atmosphere that survived the modern building, closer to old-school China market chaos than anything in central Beijing
- Depth in fashion knockoffs: bags, watches, and sneakers in multiple quality tiers, with vendors showing catalog photos first and producing the goods after negotiation
- Mixed traffic: enough local and expat shoppers to keep prices honest relative to the Silk Market
- Electronics accessories — cables, cases, headphones — at genuinely good prices (stick to accessories, not devices)
The catch:
- English is thinner; transactions run on calculators and phone translation
- Touts at the metro exits are pushier — a firm “bú yào” (don’t want) or silence plus steady walking works
- It’s in Pudong: easy on Line 2, but a deliberate trip rather than something you stumble into
Stay nearby: Base near People’s Square or the Bund on Line 2 and AP Plaza is 3–5 stops away — see Shanghai hotel deals on Trip.com.
Prices and Quality: The Detail That Actually Matters
Both markets sell from the same supply chains — the difference is markup. Expect these patterns:
Opening prices:
- Silk Market vendors typically open at 8–10x a fair price, and their tourist-trained English makes the pitch polished
- AP Plaza vendors open at 5–8x, with more room to maneuver
Realistic settling prices (after proper bargaining):
- A “AAA grade” handbag: Silk Market ¥500–900; AP Plaza ¥350–600
- A watch: Silk Market ¥400–800; AP Plaza ¥250–500
- Silk scarf (genuine silk): Silk Market ¥80–200; AP Plaza less common — buy silk in Beijing
- Sneakers: Silk Market ¥300–500; AP Plaza ¥200–350
Quality tiers exist at both. Vendors grade their own stock (A, AA, AAA — marketing terms, not standards). The rule of thumb: inspect zippers, stitching, and logo alignment yourself; never buy from a photo without seeing the physical item; and treat all “leather” claims with suspicion below ¥400.
The customs reality (identical in both cities): buying counterfeits in China carries no risk to you locally, but customs in the EU, UK, US, and Australia can seize branded fakes on arrival. Small personal quantities are usually just confiscated; large quantities can bring fines. Plan your purchases accordingly — or stick to the unbranded goods and legitimate silk, where the value is often better anyway.
Bargaining at Each Market: Same Game, Different Style
At the Silk Market, bargaining is polished theater. Vendors will grab your arm, call you friend, and produce a calculator within seconds. The rhythm: they type a number, you type one at 10–15% of it, they react with theatrical pain, you walk, they chase. Their English is good enough that charm is part of their toolkit — don’t mistake friendliness for a fair price.
At AP Plaza, it’s faster and rougher. Less English, more calculator. Counter at 10–20% of the opening price, expect shorter negotiations, and use the walk-away early — alleys are dense with near-identical stalls, so your leverage is always one turn away.
Universal rules for both:
- Never accept the first price — it’s a test
- Settle at 25–35% of the opening quote
- Inspect everything before paying; all sales are final
- Small bills or mobile pay (Alipay/WeChat work at virtually all stalls)
- Stay smiling — it’s a game, and the vendors respect good players
Which Should You Visit? A Simple Decision Guide
Choose the Silk Market if:
- Beijing is on your itinerary and Shanghai isn’t
- You want silk garments, bedding, or scarves (its strongest legitimate category)
- You value English-friendly vendors and easy logistics from the CBD
- You want the spectacle more than the bargain
Choose AP Plaza if:
- Shanghai is on your itinerary — especially with a Line 2 hotel base
- You’re focused on bags, watches, sneakers, or electronics accessories
- You enjoy harder bargaining and lower prices over polish
- You want the “underground bazaar” atmosphere that feels like old China
Do both if: you’re riding the Beijing–Shanghai high-speed train anyway. Silk Market on a Beijing morning, AP Plaza on a Shanghai afternoon — and you’ll immediately feel the price difference this guide describes. (Book train tickets in English with your passport on Trip.com — G trains take 4.5–6 hours.)
Skip both if: counterfeits don’t interest you. Put your budget into Shanghai’s South Bund Fabric Market (custom tailoring) or Beijing’s Panjiayuan flea market (curios) instead — better value, better stories, zero customs risk.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Beijing Silk Market still open?
Yes. The Silk Market operates in its seven-story building at 8 Xiushui East Street, near Yong’anli station (Line 1), open daily from around 9:30 a.m. to 9 p.m. The original outdoor alley market closed in 2005 when vendors moved into the current building.
Is AP Plaza Shanghai still open?
Yes. AP Plaza operates inside the Science & Technology Museum metro station (Line 2, Pudong), open daily from around 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. First-time visitors often miss it — the market is underground; follow the mall corridors and escalators down from the station exits.
Which is cheaper, the Silk Market or AP Plaza?
AP Plaza, typically by 20–30% for equivalent goods. The Silk Market’s foot traffic is almost entirely foreign tourists, which inflates prices; AP Plaza’s mix of local, expat, and tourist shoppers keeps vendors more competitive.
Can I bargain at both markets?
Bargaining is mandatory at both. Opening prices run 5–10x fair value. Counter at 10–20% of the asking price, settle at 25–35%, and use the walk-away freely — it’s the strongest move in your toolkit at either market.
Is it legal to buy from these markets?
Buying at the markets carries no legal risk for tourists in China. The risk is at home: customs authorities in the EU, UK, US, Australia, and elsewhere can seize counterfeit branded goods. Legitimate purchases at these markets — silk, unbranded items, tea, souvenirs — are completely fine.
Which market is better for silk products?
The Beijing Silk Market — it’s in the name and in the heritage. Its upper floors carry genuine silk garments, scarves, and bedding at good prices after bargaining. Shanghai’s AP Plaza focuses on fashion and accessories; for silk in Shanghai, shop Nanjing Road’s established stores instead.
Related read:Shanghai Disney Resort: Complete 2026 Guide
Related read:Shanghai Haichang Ocean Park: Complete 2026 Guide
Related read:The Bund Shanghai: Complete 2026 Visitor Guide
Related read:Oriental Pearl Radio & Television Tower: Complete 2026 Visitor Guide
Related read:Huangpu River Cruise: Complete 2026 Visitor Guide
Related read:LEGOLAND Shanghai Resort: Complete 2026 Visitor Guide
Related read:Yu Garden: Complete 2026 Visitor Guide